Best Eggnog 2025. Donate for the first time or increase your monthly donation to have a positive impact for independent and trusted journalism before the calendar flips to 2025. In this test, southern comfort traditional eggnog really made our team’s spirits bright.

That’s because it checked off every wish on our list. We tried eight varieties, including southern comfort, lactaid, turkey hill, and organic valley, to find the best eggnog you can buy at the supermarket.